Jedidiah Murphy was sentenced to death by the State of Texas for the murder of Bertie Lee Cunningham
According to court documents Jedidiah Murphy would force seventy nine year old Bertie Lee Cunningham into the trunk of her car. The elderly woman was driven to a remote location where she was fatally shot
Jedidiah Murphy was arrested, convicted and sentenced to death
Jedidiah Murphy Photos
Jedidiah Murphy Now
| Name | Murphy, Jedidiah Isaac | |
| TDCJ Number | 999392 | |
| Date of Birth | 09/01/1975 | |
| Date Received | 07/26/2001 | |
| Age (when Received) | 25 | |
| Education Level (Highest Grade Completed) | 12 | |
| Date of Offense | 10/04/2000 | |
| Age (at the time of Offense) | 25 | |
| County | Dallas | |
| Race | White | |
| Gender | Male | |
| Hair Color | Brown | |
| Height (in Feet and Inches) | 5′ 7″ | |
| Weight (in Pounds) | 155 | |
| Eye Color | Brown | |
| Native County | Sutton | |
| Native State | Texas |
Jedidiah Murphy Case
After robbing 80-year-old Bertie Cunningham at gunpoint, Jedidiah Isaac Murphy forced her into the trunk of her own car and shot her in the head. He then drove around with her body in the trunk, using her ATM card and credit cards to buy beer and liquor. Murphy was soon arrested. He admitted to the shooting and led police to the creek where he had dumped Cunningham’s body. Later at the police station, he wrote and signed a statement claiming that he accidentally shot Cunningham while forcing her into her own trunk.
In June 2001, a Texas jury convicted Murphy of capital murder. The State of Texas sought the death penalty. During the penalty phase of the trial, the sides clashed over the future threat to society Murphy would pose if allowed to live.
In particular, the severity of Murphy’s history of violence was a point of contention. To demonstrate he had such a history, the State submitted Murphy’s record of theft convictions. A responding officer also testified for the State about a domestic-abuse call involving Murphy and his girlfriend. The officer said that when he entered Murphy’s home, the girlfriend had a bloody nose and Murphy had a knife. The officer subdued Murphy with pepper spray. Another State witness said that Murphy pulled a gun on her at a high school party. He put the gun to her head, asked if she was afraid to die, and held it there for a minute. One of Murphy’s coworkers also testified for the State. She claimed that Murphy talked about having access to guns, bragged about shooting people, and threatened to “knock [her] fucking head off.” The woman was so frightened that she quit her job and reported Murphy to the police.
Along with this, the State tried to implicate Murphy in a three-year-old kidnapping case. Sheryl Wilhelm testified for the State that, three years before the Cunningham killing, a man briefly kidnapped her and then stole her car. After seeing a TV news report on Cunningham’s murder featuring Murphy’s photo, Wilhelm called the police to report Murphy as her kidnapper. She identified Murphy during a pretrial hearing and then again at trial. Wilhelm also testified at trial that she identified Murphy in a police-constructed photo lineup. The detective who conducted the photo lineup testified that Wilhelm’s “was one of the better photo” identifications he ever had. According to the detective, Wilhelm said “she was virtually sure that that was the guy who abducted her.”
Murphy attacked Wilhelm’s identification in a few ways. He called a psychologist who testified that Wilhelm’s memory was tainted by the photo of Murphy she saw on the news. The psychologist also pointed out prominent differences between a composite sketch, made just a week after the kidnapping, and the press-released photo of Murphy. And the psychologist added that the photo lineup was unfairly constructed; obvious differences between the mugshots reduced the odds of selection from one-in-six to one-in-three. Murphy also put on an alibi defense. Wilhelm said she had been kidnapped, escaped, and had her car stolen at 11:30 a.m. in Arlington, Texas. The day after her kidnapping, Wilhelm’s car was found in Wichita Falls, Texas. In the car, the police found documents belonging to another woman. That
901 F.3d 584
woman had been assaulted and had her purse stolen in Wichita Falls at 8:24 p.m. on the day of Wilhelm’s kidnapping. Also on the same day, Murphy clocked in for his night shift at 11:54 p.m. in Terrell, Texas. Murphy’s counsel argued that Murphy did not have time to kidnap Wilhelm in Arlington, rob the other woman in Wichita Falls, and make it to work in Terrell.
https://case-law.vlex.com/vid/murphy-v-davis-no-893081364
